International Program University of Puerto Rico School of Dental Medicine — Advanced Placement Program for Internationally Trained Dentists

University of Puerto Rico Dental Advanced Standing Interview: Format, Questions & Prep Guide (2026-27)

The University of Puerto Rico dental advanced standing interview is unlike anything on the mainland: it is a Spanish-language, in-person evaluation in San Juan that ends in a bench test, and no candidate is admitted without both. UPR's Advanced Placement Program compresses its selection into a single on-campus event — a personal interview conducted entirely in Spanish, plus a practical test of standard dental procedures in the School's clinical simulation laboratory. Because the invitation is issued only at the Admissions Committee's discretion and is never granted on request, your written file has to earn you the trip before your hands and your Spanish are ever scored.

All program guides

At a glance: requirements & format

Sourced from the UPR School of Dental Medicine's own Advanced Placement Program and bench-test preparatory course pages and the ADEA CAAPID program listing (last updated June 18, 2026). Dates, fees and document rules shift between cycles — confirm anything decision-critical with the Advanced Placement Program office before you pay a fee or book travel.

Degree Conferred
Doctor of Dental Medicine (D.M.D.), advanced placement pathway for internationally trained dentists
Program Length
25 months — a five-week summer calibration course followed by two full-time years covering the third and fourth years of the D.M.D. curriculum
Class Size
20 students per entering class, per the ADEA CAAPID program listing; confirm the current intake with the program office
Application Opens
August 1, 2026 through ADEA CAAPID — the same date the bench-test preparatory course begins accepting applications
Application Deadline
October 1, 2026 per the ADEA CAAPID listing; the school's own program page cites October 15 and asks applicants to file well before it — work to October 1
Bench Test
Yes — a mandatory practical test (Dental Clinical Simulation) of standard dental procedures, held on campus, with no candidate accepted without it; UPR's optional one-week preparatory course ($2,750, sessions September 28–29 and October 26–27, 2026) does not guarantee admission
Personal Interview
In person at the San Juan campus, conducted entirely in Spanish, with Spanish proficiency assessed during the interview itself; granted only at the Admissions Committee's discretion
Interview & Bench Test Fee
$175 administrative and clinical utilization fee, charged only if you are invited for the interview and bench test
TOEFL iBT
Required of every applicant to be considered; official score reporting only, since the program states that student copies of score reports are not acceptable — no numeric band or ETS school code is published, so request an official ETS report to ADEA CAAPID and confirm the current band with the program office
NBDE / INBDE
Required — pass NBDE Part I or the INBDE; official scores must be submitted to ADEA CAAPID
Credential Evaluation
ECE or WES — a course-by-course evaluation of your dental school credentials, submitted to ADEA CAAPID
Letters of Evaluation
Up to three letters accepted; the program prefers one from the dean of the dental school you graduated from
Supplemental Application
Yes — UPR SDM requires its own supplemental application on top of ADEA CAAPID, with attested English-translated copies of your diploma and transcripts, visa or immigration status, curriculum vitae and a personal statement
Application Fee
Non-refundable $50 supplemental application fee payable to the UPR School of Dental Medicine, separate from the ADEA CAAPID fee
Eligibility Floor
Minimum 2.00 GPA on a 4.00 scale from dental school, or its equivalent; U.S. citizenship or a green card is not required — the program is open to citizens, permanent residents and international applicants
Finalist Notifications
Issued in writing or electronically when the Admissions Committee invites you to the interview and bench test; notification timing is set at the committee's discretion and is not published
Start Date
June 1, 2027 — the five-week summer calibration course opens before the accelerated D.M.D. years begin
Admissions Contact
Advanced Placement Program, Office of Student Affairs A-156, UPR School of Dental Medicine, PO Box 365067, San Juan, PR 00936-5067 — Dr. José R. Matos jose.matos5@upr.edu, Manuel Centeno manuel.centeno@upr.edu, 787-758-2525 Ext. 1057

Requirements change — verify before you spend money

UPR's cycle dates, the supplemental fee and the bench-test logistics are all republished each year, and the listing and the school page already disagree on the deadline (October 1 versus October 15). Before you pay the $50 supplemental fee, the $175 interview and bench-test fee, or the $2,750 preparatory course, email jose.matos5@upr.edu or manuel.centeno@upr.edu — or call 787-758-2525 Ext. 1057 — and get the current cycle's deadline, fee schedule and bench-test rules confirmed in writing.

How the UPR advanced standing evaluation actually works

UPR runs a paperwork-then-live model with a skills gate bolted onto the end. There is no asynchronous video screen and no virtual option: the entire live evaluation happens in San Juan, on one trip, in Spanish, and it finishes with a bench test that faculty score by hand. Prepare against two facts at once — your file has to be complete and bilingual-ready before the cycle closes, and your hands have to be calibrated on unfamiliar simulation equipment on the same day you are interviewed.

  1. 1

    Stage 1: The complete-file screen — CAAPID, the supplemental application and the bilingual gate

    Your UPR cycle starts as a paperwork exercise and only ends when the Advanced Placement Program office holds every document. Applications open August 1, 2026 through ADEA CAAPID and the listing closes October 1, 2026. Before that date you need a course-by-course credential evaluation from ECE or WES, an official pass report for NBDE Part I or the INBDE reported to ADEA CAAPID, an official TOEFL iBT report, up to three letters of evaluation with one preferred from your dental school dean, attested copies of your diploma and transcripts with English translations, a copy of your visa or immigration status, a curriculum vitae and a personal statement. UPR also requires its own supplemental application and a non-refundable $50 supplemental fee payable to the School of Dental Medicine.

    Read the sequencing carefully, because it is the whole strategy. The committee screens a complete file and then decides, at its own discretion, whether to invite you to San Juan. Nothing here is scored on a curve: an unreported TOEFL or an unreturned letter does not lower your rank, it removes you from consideration. The published floor is a minimum 2.00 GPA on a 4.00 scale, but the sharper filter is bilingual readiness — the program states that Spanish proficiency is required and that it primarily targets graduates of Spanish-speaking dental schools.

    Nothing at this stage is granted on request

    The program states plainly that an interview or bench test will not be granted at a student's request and that no candidate is accepted without both. File early rather than exactly on time: the school itself says admission is highly competitive and asks applicants to apply well before the deadline, which is why a complete August file is screened differently from a complete September one.

  2. 2

    Stage 2: The invitation to San Juan — a discretionary gate you cannot ask for

    If your file clears, the program contacts you in writing or electronically to schedule a personal interview and a practical test at the School of Dental Medicine in San Juan. The invitation belongs entirely to the Admissions Committee: it decides who is invited and when, and no fixed notification date is published. Once invited, you pay a $175 administrative and clinical utilization fee for the interview and bench test. Plan the trip as one event, because that is how it is scheduled — both instruments happen on campus, together, with no remote alternative.

    This stage measures what paper cannot: whether you actually show up, in person, prepared, with the documents and the language you claimed. The committee has already spent reading time on you, and the invitation is an investment it expects to validate. The candidates who lose here are the ones who treat the invitation as a formality — arriving without rehearsing in Spanish, without knowing that the practical test examines standard dental procedures, and without budgeting the fee, the flight and the hotel.

    Treat the invitation as a deadline, not a date

    The moment you are invited, confirm the check-in time, what supplies or instruments the school provides, and what you must bring — then book refundable travel. Because notification timing sits with the committee and can be short, non-refundable fares bought before an invitation exists are the most common self-inflicted loss in this cycle.

  3. 3

    Stage 3: The Spanish-language personal interview — roughly 30 minutes with faculty

    The personal interview at UPR is conducted in Spanish, and the school states that Spanish proficiency is evaluated during the interview process itself. The available accounts describe an on-campus conversation of about 30 minutes with two interviewers, and the program does not publish whether the interviewer works from your file or from a standard question set — so prepare for both versions. This is not a translation exercise. You are being assessed on whether you can think clinically in the language the school teaches and practises in.

    Order matters here. UPR exists to supply a bilingual clinical workforce for a Spanish-speaking patient population, so a fluent, technically precise answer beats an impressive English answer delivered in halting Spanish every time. Arrive with the vocabulary of your own procedures in Spanish — diagnosis, anaesthesia, preparation, margins, occlusion, informed consent — and with an informed view of the health problems the island actually presents, because that is the patient base you are asking to join.

    Build clinical Spanish, not conversational Spanish

    Learn the words you would use chairside: instrumentos, anestesia, preparación, márgenes, oclusión, consentimiento informado. Narrate one full procedure out loud in Spanish from diagnosis to final restoration, record it, and listen back without captions. If you cannot explain a crown preparation in Spanish without switching to English, the interview will surface that within the first five minutes.

  4. 4

    Stage 4: The bench test — standard dental procedures, scored by faculty

    UPR calls it the practical test and runs it as a Dental Clinical Simulation on campus: a set of standard dental procedures is performed and examined. The school's own preparatory course tells you what will be judged — equipment handling and safety protocols, basic principles of crown preparations and fixed prosthodontic restorations, operative dentistry and the management of restorations, followed by a mock exam and individualised feedback from the same faculty who conduct the real evaluation. Faculty score your work directly, and no candidate is accepted without this test.

    This is the stage that separates UPR from most mainland advanced standing programs, and it is also the one where preparation is unambiguous. The bench test measures hand skills under observation, adherence to safety and hygiene protocol, and whether you can produce a calibrated result on equipment you did not train on. Because it is scheduled with your interview rather than in a separate window, a rushed or instrument-unfamiliar attempt cannot be offset by a strong conversation — arrive with both ready on the same morning.

    The prep course is optional, and it is not a guarantee

    UPR offers a one-week Preparatory Course for the Dental Clinical Simulation Bench Test: one week of duration, two days on site in clinical simulation, $2,750, with sessions on September 28–29 and October 26–27, 2026 and applications opening August 1, 2026. The school states that completing it does not guarantee admission in the upcoming cycle, and that you must still file a formal application and meet every evaluation requirement. The September session runs first; once it fills, registration moves to October.

What UPR's admissions committee is really evaluating

UPR publishes its requirements but not a ranked rubric, so read the six criteria below as the things this two-part live evaluation is built to measure — each one maps to a stage you can prepare, not generic interview advice.

Bilingual clinical fluency

Spanish proficiency is required and assessed during the in-person interview, which is conducted entirely in Spanish; the TOEFL iBT covers the English side. Neither substitutes for the other, so Stage 3 and the published TOEFL requirement are two separate gates you have to clear.

Board examination readiness

NBDE Part I or the INBDE must be passed before you can be considered, with official scores submitted to ADEA CAAPID. Stage 1 screening reads that record alongside the mandatory 2.00 GPA floor from dental school.

Manual dexterity under observation

The bench test is a mandatory practical evaluation of standard dental procedures scored by faculty in the School's simulation laboratory. Stage 4 exists because UPR will not form a judgement about your hands from a transcript.

Commitment to Puerto Rico's patients

The program states that it primarily targets dentists trained at Spanish-speaking dental schools and that it serves a bilingual clinical workforce. Questions about the island's health problems and your plans after graduation map directly to that published intent.

Document discipline and deadline control

The committee acts only on complete files, and the window is tight — August 1 to October 1 on the listing, with the school's own page citing October 15 and asking for early filing. A missing translation or an unreported score costs a full cycle.

Awareness of the licensure pathway

Applicants who intend to practise in Puerto Rico must satisfy the Puerto Rico Dental Board, including 90 semester hours or 135 quarter hours of predental coursework with 12 semester hours of Spanish. The school considers applicants who do not meet that coursework requirement, but you should know the rule before you enrol.

University of Puerto Rico dental advanced standing interview questions (with coaching notes)

These are the prompts this program's evaluation is built around, grouped by what each category measures. The interview is delivered in Spanish, so rehearse every answer in Spanish until the wording is automatic rather than translated in real time — and treat the bench-day set as prompts you will either be asked aloud or have to demonstrate on a tyrodont. Say each answer out loud before you rely on it.

Motivational & background

5 questions
1

Tell me about yourself and your background.

How to answer
Build a 90-second arc, not a curriculum vitae recital: where you trained, the clinical work you do now, why you want to move into the U.S. system, and why UPR's Advanced Placement Program is the route. The interview is in Spanish, so the arc has to be fluent, not mentally translated. The trap is listing qualifications in chronological order instead of building a case.

2

Why did you choose dentistry?

How to answer
Answer with a concrete origin — a patient you treated, a public-health problem in your community, a family or clinical experience — and then connect it to what you do now. Keep it short: the interviewer is checking that your motivation is stable, not admiring the story. The trap is a speech about helping people that could belong to any applicant.

3

Why are you interested in the University of Puerto Rico Advanced Placement Program specifically?

How to answer
Name the structural facts: the 25-month pathway into the third and fourth years of the D.M.D., the five-week summer calibration course, the bilingual San Juan clinical environment, and the bench-test pathway that values hands and not only grades. Add one honest reason the island fits your career. The trap is a generic reputation answer that proves you never read the program page.

4

Where do you see yourself in ten years?

How to answer
Give a specific trajectory — private practice in a defined setting, a residency or specialty, public health on the island, academia — and tie it to why you are entering this program now. If you intend to practise in Puerto Rico, say so and show you know the Puerto Rico Dental Board's coursework rules. The trap is naming a specialty whose path you cannot explain.

5

What do you know about our curriculum?

How to answer
Prove you have read past the headline: five weeks of summer calibration, then two full-time years alongside third and fourth year D.M.D. students, in a school where teaching and clinic run in Spanish and English. Mention the simulation laboratory as the place your bench skills get assessed and built. The trap is describing a curriculum you have invented.

Behavioral

4 questions
6

How do you handle stress and pressure?

How to answer
This is a proxy for surviving a 25-month accelerated program in a second language. Name your actual mechanism — a schedule, a study group, physical exercise, deliberate prioritisation — and give one period when it was tested, such as preparing for the INBDE while working. The trap is claiming you simply do not feel pressure.

7

Tell us about a challenge you overcame.

How to answer
Choose one real obstacle with a visible cost: a course you failed and retook, a clinic shortage you worked around, a move to a new country, a credential backlog. State the barrier, what you did, the result, and what you changed afterwards. The trap is a story where nothing was at stake or where the resolution depended entirely on someone else.

8

What are your greatest strengths as a candidate, and what is your biggest weakness?

How to answer
Pick one strength with a clinical or academic proof point — volume of patients treated, a technique you are known for, a research or teaching thread — then choose a weakness already under active management, such as documentation speed or delegation. Say what you changed. A disguised strength like perfectionism reads as evasive to a faculty panel.

9

How will you handle the transition to the U.S. dental system?

How to answer
Show you understand what actually changes: infection control and documentation standards, informed consent, insurance and billing, four-handed delivery, and being supervised again after running your own practice. Name one thing you have already done to close a gap. The trap is treating the transition as purely linguistic.

Ethical & scenario

4 questions
10

Describe an ethical dilemma you have faced and how you handled it.

How to answer
Choose a situation with competing goods — a patient refusing a needed referral, a billing or record error, a colleague cutting corners — then walk through how you identified the obligation, who you consulted, and what you documented. In a jurisdiction-specific licensing environment, the winning pattern is escalation and documentation rather than improvisation. The trap is a dilemma with an obvious villain.

11

A patient cannot afford the treatment you have diagnosed. What do you do?

How to answer
Hold both obligations at once: clinical integrity on the diagnosis and pragmatism on the plan. Sequence the treatment over time, discuss alternative materials or staged options honestly, and know when to refer to a low-cost or public clinic. In Puerto Rico, where uninsured and Medicare-dependent patients are common, this question is closer to daily practice than you may expect. Never present a substandard option as equivalent.

12

You notice a colleague has falsified a clinical record or skipped infection control. What do you do?

How to answer
Separate the immediate patient-safety step from the professional one: address or stop the risk first, then raise it with the person directly and escalate through the supervising faculty or the appropriate office, documenting as you go. Say plainly that you would not sign a record you knew to be false. The trap is agreeing that loyalty to a colleague outranks the patient.

13

A patient does not speak the language most of the clinic staff use. How do you handle consent and treatment?

How to answer
Use a qualified interpreter rather than a family member, confirm comprehension by asking the patient to explain the plan back, and document that the consent was obtained in a language the patient understands. This is your chance to show bilingual practice as a clinical skill, not a courtesy. The trap is treating broken language as adequate for a legal consent.

Bench-day & Spanish-language prompts

3 questions
14

Describe any current activities and/or hobbies that require hand skills.

How to answer
Answer with something you genuinely do and can describe in detail — an instrument, woodworking, cooking, drawing, repairs, needlework — and connect it explicitly to precision under magnification, spatial judgement, or steady hands. Naming a habit is not enough; describe the technique. The trap is claiming a hobby you could not discuss for two follow-up questions.

15

What are the main causes of death in the adult population in Puerto Rico?

How to answer
This is a population-knowledge question, and it is asked because you are applying to serve the island's patients. Speak to the chronic-disease and cardiometabolic burden, cancer, and the role of diabetes and hypertension, and then connect it to dentistry — periodontal disease, glycaemic control, oral cancer screening. The trap is answering with mainland epidemiology you have not checked against the island.

16

In Spanish, walk us through a procedure you perform often, from diagnosis to final restoration.

How to answer
Choose one procedure — a full-coverage crown, a composite restoration, an extraction — and narrate it in five beats: findings and diagnosis, plan and consent, anaesthesia and isolation, preparation or execution, and final check or cementation. Use the correct Spanish clinical vocabulary throughout. The trap is describing the outcome while skipping the safety and margin checks the bench-day faculty are specifically trained to watch.

Want feedback on your answers — not just the questions?

Practice these questions free

Your UPR advanced standing preparation timeline

Work backwards from the October 1, 2026 listing deadline and the June 1, 2027 program start, and treat the earlier of UPR's two published deadlines as the one that counts. The two things that wreck this cycle are a credential evaluation ordered too late and a bench test attempted on equipment you have never touched.

  1. 16–20 weeks before the October 1 deadline (May–June 2026)

    • Confirm your NBDE Part I or INBDE pass and that official scores are reportable to ADEA CAAPID
    • Book the TOEFL iBT early and request official ETS reporting — student copies of score reports are not acceptable to this program
    • Start the ECE or WES course-by-course credential evaluation; these take weeks, not days
    • Request up to three letters of evaluation, with one from the dean of the dental school you graduated from
    • Check your GPA against the mandatory 2.00 floor on a 4.00 scale
    • Start daily clinical Spanish practice and record one full procedure narration a week
  2. 10–12 weeks before the October 1 deadline (mid-July 2026)

    • Write the personal statement for the Advanced Placement Program specifically, not a generic dentistry essay
    • Order attested copies of your dental school diploma and transcripts with English translations
    • Prepare a copy of your visa or immigration status and update your curriculum vitae
    • Draft answers in Spanish to the motivational and ethical prompts and time them against a 30-minute interview
    • Decide whether you will sit the bench-test preparatory course and budget the $2,750 now rather than in October
  3. August 1, 2026 — CAAPID opens and the prep course window opens

    • Submit the ADEA CAAPID application rather than waiting for the deadline
    • Pay the non-refundable $50 supplemental fee to the UPR School of Dental Medicine and complete the supplemental application
    • Register for the bench-test preparatory course if you want it — applications open August 1, sessions are September 28–29 and October 26–27
    • Confirm in writing with the program office which deadline applies to your cycle, October 1 or October 15
  4. September–October 2026 — deadline control

    • Submit every remaining document at least two weeks before October 1 so corrections are still possible
    • Attend the September 28–29 simulation days if registered; if that session fills, take October 26–27
    • Email jose.matos5@upr.edu or manuel.centeno@upr.edu to confirm receipt of each item, including the supplemental fee
    • Keep a dated record of every submission in case a document is disputed later
  5. The invitation window (at the committee's discretion)

    • Monitor your email daily — invitations are issued in writing or electronically, and no notification date is published
    • Budget the $175 administrative and clinical utilization fee for the interview and bench test
    • Book refundable flights and accommodation in San Juan only once the invitation is in hand
    • Confirm what instruments, supplies and documents you must bring, and what the school provides
  6. Interview and bench test day in San Juan

    • Arrive the day before and walk the campus so venue logistics are not part of your first morning
    • Bring photo identification and every document the program asked for
    • Rehearse in Spanish the night before: the 90-second introduction, your procedure narration, and your questions
    • Ask the faculty how the simulation units are calibrated and get your hands on the equipment before timing starts
    • Complete the procedure checks — margins, contacts, occlusion, hygiene protocol — rather than racing to finish
  7. After the evaluation, before the June 1, 2027 start

    • Watch for electronic notification of the committee's decision; timing is at its discretion, so keep your email address current
    • If you plan to practise in Puerto Rico, verify the Puerto Rico Dental Board coursework requirement — 90 semester hours or 135 quarter hours, including 12 semester hours of Spanish
    • Request the program's current tuition and cost estimate for the advanced placement class and plan financing
    • Prepare visa and financial documentation well before the summer calibration course begins

UPR advanced standing interview — frequently asked questions

What is the University of Puerto Rico advanced standing interview format?

It is an in-person, on-campus evaluation in San Juan, not a virtual screen. Invited candidates sit a personal interview conducted entirely in Spanish and a practical test known as the bench test, usually scheduled together on the same trip. The available accounts describe roughly 30 minutes with two interviewers. UPR states that neither the interview nor the bench test is granted at a student's request, and that no candidate is accepted without both.

Does UPR require a bench test for the Advanced Placement Program?

Yes. The ADEA CAAPID listing for the program shows Bench Test as Yes, and the school's own page calls it a practical test in which a set of standard dental procedures is examined. It is held on site in the School's clinical simulation laboratory, faculty score your work directly, and no candidate is accepted without an interview and a bench test.

Is the UPR interview really conducted in Spanish?

Yes. UPR states that the personal interview is conducted in Spanish and that Spanish proficiency is evaluated during the interview process. Proficiency in Spanish is a stated requirement, the school primarily targets graduates of Spanish-speaking dental schools, and coursework and clinic run in both Spanish and English. Rehearse your answers in Spanish rather than translating them in the room.

What TOEFL score does UPR require?

All applicants must take the TOEFL iBT to be considered, and the program states that student copies of score reports are not acceptable, so official ETS reporting to ADEA CAAPID is required. UPR does not publish a numeric minimum band or an ETS school code in its listings. Confirm the current score band and reporting details with the program office before you book your test date.

What are the UPR application deadline and start date?

The ADEA CAAPID listing shows the application opening August 1, 2026 and closing October 1, 2026, with the program starting June 1, 2027. The School of Dental Medicine's own page cites an application window of August 1 to October 15 and encourages applicants to file well before that deadline. Treat October 1 as the date that governs your cycle.

How large is the UPR advanced placement class?

The program size published on the ADEA CAAPID listing is 20 students for a 25-month program. That is a small cohort entering the third and fourth years of the D.M.D. curriculum after a five-week summer calibration course, which means chair time and faculty attention are shared with a limited group. Confirm the current intake with the Advanced Placement Program office.

Which credential evaluation services does UPR accept?

The ADEA CAAPID listing names Educational Credential Evaluators (ECE) and World Education Services (WES), and the school's own page directs candidates to an international credential evaluation service for proper evaluation of dental credentials, with ece.org as its example. Order a course-by-course evaluation and send it to ADEA CAAPID well before the deadline, since processing takes weeks.

How many letters of evaluation does UPR require?

The program accepts up to three letters of evaluation and prefers one to come from the dean of the dental school from which you graduated. The school's own requirements page asks for three letters of reference, preferably from dental school faculty. Submit them through ADEA CAAPID, and choose people who can speak to your clinical work rather than only your coursework.

What fees does the UPR advanced placement application involve?

Three separate costs, all published: the non-refundable $50 supplemental application fee payable to the UPR School of Dental Medicine, the $175 administrative and clinical utilization fee charged if you are invited to the interview and bench test, and the optional one-week bench-test preparatory course at $2,750. The ADEA CAAPID application fee is charged separately by ADEA. None of these fees is refundable if you are not admitted.

When do UPR applicants hear whether they are invited?

The school states that all candidates are informed electronically of the action taken on their applications, and that notification timing is set at the discretion of the Admissions Committee. No fixed decision date is published. That is precisely why you should file early, keep your email address current, and avoid non-refundable travel until an invitation arrives in writing.

Practice the UPR interview out loud — in Spanish

Reading about a Spanish-language interview and a bench test covers maybe half of this page's value. The other half is speaking 30 minutes of structured clinical Spanish under pressure and narrating a procedure without reaching for English. Our AI interview practice scores your structure and delivery instantly, so you can run the reps before the conversation that actually counts in San Juan.

Start free AI interview practice

Interviewing anywhere else this cycle? Our MMI preparation guide covers the multiple-mini-interview format used by many advanced standing programs, and the AI interview practice tool lets you rehearse any program's questions out loud with instant feedback. If you are still building your school list, browse the dental advanced standing program guides to compare deadlines, bench-test rules and interview formats side by side.